Why does "why are you leaving" get follow-up questions?
The why are you leaving answer gives a reason, and the follow-ups test whether it is complete, current and safe. Saint Mary's University of Minnesota tells students to "expect interviewers to have several follow-up questions and probe for details" (Saint Mary's University of Minnesota). A reason for leaving is one sentence, so the probing starts quickly.
The follow-ups also tend to stay on your answer. Canada's Public Service Commission tells its hiring boards that probing questions "should not result in the introduction of new topics or issues" (Public Service Commission of Canada). Whatever you said about pay, growth, a manager or a layoff is the ground the next questions cover.
The first answer is covered in how to answer why are you leaving your current job, along with three short follow-ups: whether you raised it with your manager, what would make you stay and whether your employer knows. This page covers six more that the reason itself invites.
Which follow-ups does a reason for leaving invite?
A reason for leaving invites follow-ups about timing, repetition, pay, references, balance and, if you've already left, how it ended. Each one checks something different. The table lists the six, what each checks and where answers tend to break, and the sections below give an example reply for each.
| Follow-up | What it checks | Where answers tend to break |
|---|---|---|
| "Why now?" | Whether something specific changed, or you're drifting | No trigger event, only general restlessness |
| "How do we know you won't leave us for the same reason?" | Whether this job fixes your reason | The candidate hasn't checked that it does |
| "What are you making now?" | Your pay history, which some laws bar employers from asking | The candidate volunteers a number without meaning to |
| "Can we speak to your manager?" | Whether your account matches what a reference would say | A hesitant answer that suggests a bad exit |
| "What will you miss about the job?" | Whether you can be fair about your employer | Nothing comes to mind, or the answer is sarcastic |
| "Are you still there?" | Whether you left or were let go, and how you describe it | A defensive or vague account of the exit |
The table lists follow-ups that a reason for leaving invites, based on published guidance on how interviewers probe. It does not rank them by how often they come up.
What does "why now" check?
The why-now follow-up checks whether a specific change prompted the search or you are restless in general. Canada's Public Service Commission gives sample probes such as "Why did you take that approach?" and "When did all this take place?" (Public Service Commission of Canada). "Why now" is the same probe applied to your job search.
The answer breaks when no trigger exists. "I've been there four years" is a length of time, not a reason. Name the event: a reorganization, a promotion that went to an outside hire, a product being shut down, a move.
Example reply to "Why now?": Our team was merged into another department in June, and the analytics work I was hired for moved to a central group. I've been doing reporting since, which is a smaller job than the one I took.
How do you answer "how do we know you won't leave us for the same reason"?
The won't-you-leave-us-too follow-up checks whether you've confirmed that this job fixes what made you leave the last one. Google's re:Work guide gives "Moving forward, what's your plan?" as a sample follow-up to a behavioral question (Google re:Work). Your plan has to connect your reason for leaving to something in this role.
The answer breaks when the candidate hasn't checked. If you're leaving for growth, you should know what growth looks like here. Ask about it earlier in the process, or read the posting for it.
Example reply to "How do we know you won't leave for the same reason?": I left because there was no path from analyst to team lead. Your posting says this role leads two analysts within the first year, and the recruiter confirmed it. That's the step I couldn't take where I am.
This follow-up often leads into why do you want to work here, so keep the two answers pointing the same way.
What do you do when asked "what are you making now"?
The what-are-you-making-now follow-up asks for your salary history, which some places bar employers from seeking. California Labor Code section 432.3 says an employer "shall not, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, seek salary history information" about an applicant (California Legislative Information). The same section lets employers ask about your salary expectation.
The answer breaks when a candidate who left for pay volunteers a number without meaning to. Under section 432.3, an applicant may disclose salary history "voluntarily and without prompting," and the employer may then rely on it. So decide before the interview whether you want to share it.
Example reply to "What are you making now?": I'd rather focus on this role. Based on the scope and the range in the posting, I'm looking for something between 95,000 and 105,000 dollars.
California is one example. Rules differ by state, province and city, so check the law where the job is. The guide to answering what are your salary expectations covers how to pick the range.
What does "can we speak to your manager" check?
The can-we-speak-to-your-manager follow-up checks whether the story you told would match what a reference says. Some employers state that they check. Greenhouse's candidate guidelines say it "may contact references to verify key qualifications and experiences you've represented in our interview process, and we'll let you know before we do" (Greenhouse).
The answer breaks when the candidate hesitates, because a pause suggests the exit is worse than described. If your current employer doesn't know you're looking, say so and offer someone else.
Example reply to "Can we speak to your manager?": Not yet, since my manager doesn't know I'm looking. I can give you a former manager from my last role now, and my current manager's details once we're at the offer stage.
Keep your reason for leaving consistent with what that former manager would say. The debrief template is a free, one-page way to write down what you said in each interview so the account stays the same.
What does "what will you miss" check?
The what-will-you-miss follow-up checks whether you can be fair about the employer you're leaving. Saint Mary's University of Minnesota says behavioral interviewers will "probe further for more depth or detail" (Saint Mary's University of Minnesota). Asking what you'll miss probes the other side of your reason.
The answer breaks when nothing comes to mind, or the reply is a joke about leaving. Either one makes the reason for leaving sound like a grievance. Name one real thing.
Example reply to "What will you miss?": The people on my team. We've worked together for three years and we hand work off without needing meetings. I'd want to build that again.
How do you answer "are you still there"?
The are-you-still-there follow-up checks whether you left, were let go or are still employed, and how calmly you describe it. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says federal law "does not prevent employers from asking about unemployed status," though the federal EEO laws bar using it to discriminate (EEOC).
The answer breaks when the candidate turns vague or defensive about how the job ended. If you were laid off, say so in a sentence and move to what you've done since. If you were fired, say what happened and what changed.
Example reply to "Are you still there?": No, my role was eliminated in a reduction in September, along with about a fifth of the company. Since then I've finished two freelance projects and focused on this search.
For more on this, see the guide to explaining a layoff in an interview.
How do you prepare for these follow-ups?
Preparing for why are you leaving follow-ups means writing one line for each of the six before the interview. Note the event that started the search, the part of this job that fixes your reason, your pay range, a reference you can offer now, one thing you'll miss and a one-sentence account of how the job ended if it has.
Say each line out loud and keep it under 20 seconds. If two of your lines disagree, fix the story before an interviewer finds the gap. The free interview questions tool lists likely questions for a job you paste in, with what the interviewer listens for.
The same method works for other openers: the follow-ups after tell me about yourself, after the greatest weakness question, after a conflict with a coworker and after what do you do.
To rehearse the reason and its follow-ups out loud, the Prept Mock room asks questions on a clock and scores each answer out of 10 against your resume, in the free plan.